Main Cottage
Best for families, groups, more space, a private hot tub, and a full lake-house feel.
📍 Brantingham Lake, New York
Private-Island Stays on Brantingham Lake
Choose your island setup: Main Cottage, tiny cabins, waterfront glamping, The Floater houseboat, or the entire island.
🚤 Boat-in arrival
🐾 Dog-friendly options
♨️ Hot tub access
📶 Wi‑Fi
🏝️ Direct booking
Already have dates?
Search live availability and direct rates, or browse the options below.
Not sure which stay fits?
Use the date search above if you know your timing, or scroll down to compare the Main Cottage, tiny cabins, glamping, houseboat, and entire-island options before opening the matching Guesty listing.
Choose your stay
Which Grant Island option fits your trip?
Start with the kind of trip you want. Then check dates, compare details, or ask us which setup fits best.
Tiny Cabins
Best for couples or two guests who want the island experience with a simpler setup.
Waterfront Glamping
Best for something outdoorsy, unusual, and close to the water.
Houseboat
Best for the most different stay — waking up right on the lake.
Entire Island
Best for larger groups that want the most private Grant Island experience.
Book direct
Book Direct & Avoid OTA Fees
Before booking Grant Island through a major platform, check direct pricing first. Booking direct may save money on longer stays and lets us help you choose the right setup before you reserve.
Compare stays
All Grant Island stay options
Use the filters to narrow the page. Each card opens the matching Guesty listing with live availability and direct pricing.
Best for groups
Live direct rates
Main Cottage — Sleeps 8
Best for families and groups that want the most space, private hot tub, and a full lake-house feel.
Most unusual
Live direct rates
The Floater Houseboat — Sleeps 2
Best if you want the most different experience and like the idea of waking up right on the lake.
Outdoorsy + unique
Live direct rates
Waterfront Glamping — Sleeps 3
Best for guests who want something outdoorsy, unique, and right on the water.
Couples retreat
Live direct rates
Stabbin Cabin #2 — Sleeps 2
Best for a simple two-person private-island stay with electric boat and shared island amenities.
Tiny cabin
Live direct rates
Stabbin Cabin — Sleeps 2
Best for two guests who want a smaller island stay and easy access to shared island amenities.
Most private
Check availability
Entire Island Option
Best for larger groups that want the most private version of the Grant Island experience.
How the island works
A boat-in stay without needing to own a boat.
Grant Island is not a normal drive-up rental. That is what makes it memorable — and why we explain the process before you choose dates.
1
Park on the mainland
Guests arrive at the mainland parking area before heading to the island.
2
Arrive by boat
We bring you over, get you situated, and explain how the island access works.
3
Choose the right setup
Cottage, cabin, glamping, houseboat, or entire island — the best fit depends on your group and trip style.
Quick comparison
Compare the island setups
Use this table to avoid booking the wrong setup. Final details should always be checked on the individual listing before reserving.
| Stay | Sleeps | Best for | Bathroom | Hot tub | Boat / Access | Pets |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Main Cottage | 8 | Families, groups, more space | Private | Private | Boat-in arrival + boat access | Dog-friendly |
| Stabbin Cabin | 2 | Couples / two guests | Shared island facilities | Shared island amenity | Electric boat / canoe access | Dog-friendly rules vary |
| Stabbin Cabin #2 | 2 | Couples / two guests | Shared nearby bathroom building | Shared island amenity | Electric boats + canoe | Dog-friendly rules vary |
| Waterfront Glamping | 3 | Outdoorsy lakefront stay | Private/nearby facilities — confirm listing | Shared island amenity | Private electric boat + private dock | Dog-friendly rules vary |
| The Floater | 2 | Houseboat / most unusual stay | Island bathroom/shower building | Shared island amenity | Electric boat + rowboat/canoe access | Dog-friendly rules vary |
| Entire Island | Confirm | Larger groups / most private | Mixed by stay | Mixed by stay | Multiple island access options | Confirm by group |
Note: Guesty is now the direct-booking source of truth for availability and pricing. Final property-specific logistics should still be confirmed before booking.
Common questions
Things people ask before booking
Grant Island is easy to enjoy, but it is different from a normal cottage rental.
Do we need our own boat?
No. Guests arrive at the mainland parking area, and we bring you over by boat. We get you situated and explain how the island access works.
Is the whole island private?
Only if you book the entire island. Otherwise, other rentals may also be occupied and some amenities may be shared.
Can we bring a dog?
Grant Island has dog-friendly options, but rules vary by stay. Tell us your dog’s size and which dates you are considering so we can point you to the right option.
Is there Wi‑Fi?
Yes, Wi‑Fi is available. Signal strength can vary depending on the stay and location on the island, so ask if reliable work connectivity matters for your trip.
Is there a hot tub?
The Main Cottage has its own private hot tub. Smaller stays have access to shared island hot tub amenities.
How do bathrooms work?
It depends on the stay. The Main Cottage has its own bathroom; some smaller island stays use nearby bathroom/shower facilities. Check the listing or ask before booking.
What are check-in and check-out times?
Standard check-in is 1:00 PM and check-out is 10:00 AM. Paid late checkout may be available depending on same-day turns.
Next step
Ready to choose your island stay?
Check available dates if you know your timing, or email your dates and guest count if you want help choosing the best setup.